Touching
From A Distance: Ian Curtis And Joy Division
by
Deborah Curtis (Faber & Faber)
When
I was a suicidal teenager, my favorite band was Joy Division. There
was something so soothing about singing along to lyrics like, "Directionless,
so plain to see / A loaded gun won't set you free / So you say"
or "Existence, well what does it matter?". In fact, my entire
teenage experience could be summed up by a couple of Ian Curtis verses:
"Oh,
how I realized how I wanted time
Put into perspective, tried so hard to find
Just for one moment thought I'd found my way
Destiny unfolded, I watched it slip away"
"Now
that I've realized how it's all gone wrong
Gotta find some therapy, this treatment takes too long
Deep in the heart of where sympathy held sway
Gotta find my destiny before it gets too late"
Luckily,
I was able to find my destiny... er, is that was this is?... before
it got too late. Ian Curtis was not as fortunate; he hung himself
on May 18, 1980. That's a date that I know from memory; Ian's suicide
was a signalpost of my youth. I knew somewhere in the back of my
mind that it was probably not a good idea to worship a suicide,
but I couldn't help myself. My doomed romanticism was at its most
sharply tuned during those dark days in the 1980's and I spent my
days cloistered in my room listening to Joy Division, reading Sylvia
Plath and Anne Sexton, and writing my own gloomy (and piss-poor)
poetry. It wasn't much of a life, but it was a living...
I've
weathered a lot of rugged emotional terrain since those teenage
years, and although the specific schoolyard scenarios that tormented
me back in those days are now a distant memory, the painful emotions
that accompanied them still ring true. However, one thing has definitely
changed in my medicated mind: I'm not particularly impressed by
suicide any longer. I am far more likely to feel sympathy for the
loved ones left behind and forever scarred by the suicide than I
am for the desperate individual who committed the act. I look back
on my own nearly-successful suicide attempt with more embarrassment
than pride these days, and I'm not nearly as likely to show off
my abundant scars as I used to be 10 years ago. Is this what they
call "maturity" ... or am I just a boring old Comtesse?
Who can say?
So,
it is with this changed perspective that I read "Touching From
A Distance: Ian Curtis and Joy Division" by Ian Curtis' widow
Deborah. I'm not sure what I was expecting from this book, but I
thought I would get some understanding of how Curtis' family and
friends could just stand by and seemingly do nothing while his obvious
suicidal tendencies went fatally unchecked. The book doesn't really
answer that question - except to reinforce just how isolated Curtis
had become in his final days, and how estranged he was from his
family. If you believe Deborah's account, Ian was almost zombie-like
during his last few months, as the strain of his personal problems
(a broken marriage, a doomed love affair, and increasingly uncontrollable
epilepsy) became unbearable. After reading this book, I understand
why Curtis killed himself, and in some ways, I can't say that I
blame him.
The
book also presents Curtis as a very unlikeable personality. He is
cold, controlling, uncaring, and indifferent towards his wife. I
have to take that presentation with a grain of salt, since a lot
of it smacks of 'Embittered Ex' syndrome. Deborah doesn't seem to
have the slightest understanding of her husband, and doesn't offer
any explanation of his motivations or his artistry. They don't communicate,
don't seem to have anything in common, and they don't really seem
to like each other either. It's a pretty depressing read, but not
for obvious reasons.
There
is one additional thing that I cannot forgive Deborah Curtis for
- and that's refusing to publish Ian's suicide note in the book.
She makes reference to it as being "deeply personal" -
and I suppose this is her excuse for not printing it. But she sure
had no problem in exploiting her personal life with Ian when writing
this book! Yes, I know I'm being voyeuristic, but I can't help myself
- I want to read the note! I want to know what his last thoughts
were as he approached his "last fatal hour". Instead I'm
left with continued frustration.
My
next read on this subject will be Mick Middles' book "Torn
Apart" which presents the perspective of Curtis' girlfriend
Annik Honoré. It's supposed to be much more enlightening
than anything his wife could offer. I certainly hope so!
And
there's always Anton Corbijn's movie "Control" to look
forward to... It looks excellent!
http://members.aol.com/lwtua/these.htm
NN
- "We Were Strangers"... Indeed.
|
|